The Philadelphia Jewish Voice


Special Dossier
• War Versus Hezbollah

Top Stories
• Live From Israel
Dems Speak Out
• GOP Obstructs Support
• Hiram Bingham Stamp
• Two Different Conflicts
•  Joining the IDF
•  Mea Culpa
• McIntyre's Apology
• Arab State = Jew-Free?
• The Hammer
• Not In My Synagogue
• "Transparency" Is Black
• Where Have All The Rabbis Gone
• The Lobbies
• NIF v. ZOA
• Letters to the Editor

• We Stand With Israel
• Blood Donations
• Shalom TV

In Their Own Words
• Peter Edelman

Networking Central
• Kehillah Secular Jews

Living Judaism
• The Halacha of War
• The Tahara Experience
• Organ Donation

Raising A Mensch
• Parenting during war
• Mazel Tov... It's A Girl!

The Kosher Table
• New In The Main Line

Free Subscription

Past Issues
• July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
• February 2006
• January 2006
• December 2005
• November 2005
• October 2005
• September 2005
• August 2005
• July 2005

  About       Free Subscription       Donate       Contact Us        Links   border="0" />    Archives

Dry Bones cartoon - The Ticking Iranian Time Bomb
Grand Mufti Amin al-Husseini with an SS officer 

Why must an Arab state be Jew-free?
Expel hatred, not Jews.

-- Stephen M. Asbel

It seems that everyone who talks about trying to have an Arab-Israeli "peace settlement" takes it as a given that all Jews must be removed from all areas which will be given over to an Arab Palestinian state. However, no one ever seems to want to talk about why this is necessary. Israel within its pre-1967 borders has an Arab minority population that accounts for about 22 percent of the total. There is no significant support for any idea of forcibly removing the Arabs within the pre-1967 borders of Israel. (Avigdor Lieberman does not want to remove Arabs from Israel, but rather to remove Israel from the Arabs, but that is another topic.) Why is it that in every proposal - unilateral or negotiated - Israel will retain a large Arab minority and perhaps even face demands to take in additional Arabs, but the potential Arab Palestinian state would have to be Judenfrei - Jew-free? Of course, we are not talking only about removing live Jews, but dead ones too, as indicated by the removal of bodies from Gaza graves. The case of Israeli Jews is the only example where it is American policy (and Israeli policy) to favor the complete expulsion of an ethnic group from an area. The United States led NATO aerial bombardment campaigns to stop the expulsion of Bosnian Muslims and of Albanians in Kosovo, yet it is promoting a policy that requires the expulsion of Jews from Samaria, Gaza and Judea. While the U.S. has not fully endorsed the Olmert unilateral plan, it does favor a negotiated solution involving expulsion of Jews.

The obvious answer to why the Jews are to be removed is that the presence of Jews, especially Jews who will not submit to the humiliation of dhimmi laws (the Islamic laws applicable to certain non-Muslims), is utterly offensive to the Arab Muslims in the region. Thus, any Jews left to live under an Arab regime will face persecution, violence and death. Long-standing Arab racist intolerance, demonstrated by the historical record of how Jews in Arab lands have been treated (especially in the last sixty years), compels such a conclusion. One infamous example is the 1941 farhoud (pogrom) in Iraq, when on Shavuot, there was a pro-Nazi riot of murder, rape, and looting inspired by the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, Amin al-Husseini. This pogrom left 200 Jews dead, 2000 injured and 900 Jewish homes destroyed. 

During the 1948-49 War of Israel's Independence, Arab forces overran long-established Jewish communities in Hebron, Kfar Etzion, Kfar Darom and half of Jerusalem, including the ancient Jewish Quarter of the Old City. In every one of those locations, every Jew there either fled or was killed. Not a single Jew remained alive in the Judea, Samaria and Gaza regions which were occupied by Jordan and Egypt. Yes, Arabs fled Israeli-held areas, but largely at the urging of their own people; and while there were violent incidents against Arab civilians, those were the exception, not the rule. So, as the record shows, when the world seeks Israel's withdrawal to the 1949 lines and the expulsion of every Jew beyond them, the world is seeking to ratify the result of the Arab genocidal war launched in earnest in 1948.

That raises the next question: If the general hostility of Arabs toward Jews is so intense that not one Jew can be tolerated to live in a proposed Arab Palestinian state, then how can Israel possibly expect to live in peace with such a state, especially when there is no indication that any strong political faction among the Arab Palestinians is willing or able to accept Israel and to live in peace? I would suggest that before Israel rushes to expel Jews from the heart of the Jewish homeland in some vain hope for peace in the current political climate, there must first be a massive cultural and educational transition among the Arabs. The Arabs must overcome their long-standing, pervasive hatred of Israel and the Jews before Israel can hope to have a lasting peace with Arab neighbors. For Israel to unilaterally put its major cities in range of hostile missiles and mortars in the absence of such fundamental change is a dangerous folly.

Stephen M. Asbel is an attorney in Media, Pennsylvania. He is the author of the Saba Yeshayah Israel News and Views weblog which received four nominations in the 2005 Jerusalem Post Jewish and Israeli Blog Awards, and has had articles published by Arutz Sheva Israel National News.